Anglers Restaurant & Proper Pour offers a thoughtfully crafted menu that perfectly balances hearty American classics with fresh, vibrant seafood. Highlights include the Hoosier Tenderloin, a half-pound, house-breaded cutlet served on a toasted potato bun, and the Golden Crispy Cod Fish Tacos that come alive with tropical tequila sauce and fresh pico de gallo. For those craving comfort, the Chicken Tender Platter with special BBQ sauce and golden fries is a must-try, while the Sesame Orange Chicken features delicately grilled flounder and gulf shrimp bathed in a bright tropical glaze.

Sharables such as loaded steak fries topped with bacon and melted cheeses, house-made onion rings, and buttery pretzel sticks pair beautifully with their extensive cold drink selection, enhancing a relaxed, inviting atmosphere. The menu’s mix of bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and generous portions creates an experience that keeps guests coming back for more. Whether enjoying a casual meal or a social night out, Anglers delivers consistent quality with attentive service in Monticello’s welcoming dining scene.